Understanding this process does not guarantee that a pitcher will be his team’s closer next year. This post will assess the potential candidates after players can enter free agency, which helps set the stage for which relievers may be at the top of their hierarchy on Opening Day. It will include pending free agents and relievers with options once the World Series transpires.
As the season winds down, tips help offset costs. If we have helped out, please return the favor. If you would like to leave a tip, please use this link for PayPal. Venmo can be sent to @gjewett9.
- No pending free agents or relievers with options on the 2025 roster
- Projected 2026 Closer: Not on the current roster
This season has been disappointing for the Orioles, and if the team plans to contend, it will need to restock its bullpen. Félix Bautista suffered a significant shoulder injury and will miss a large portion of the upcoming season. The team could opt for a veteran with closer experience on a one-year deal as a bridge to Bautista’s eventual return, which makes sense. Adding a reliable right-handed set-up reliever should also be a priority for 2026.
- Pending free agent: Justin Wilson
- Reliever with an option: Liam Hendriks (Mutual for $12 million)
- Projected 2026 Closer: Aroldis Chapman
Removing speculation about next year, the team extended Aroldis Chapman. There will be games he’s deployed against an opponent’s best hitting pocket if it contains a left-handed hitter, but through games played on September 21, he has recorded 31 of his team’s 43 saves.
- Pending free agent: Tyler Alexander
- Projected 2026 Closer: Jordan Leasure
- Watch List: Peyton Pallette
In the team’s first 156 games, eight different relievers have recorded 24 saves under first-year manager Will Venable. Only two (Jordan Leasure and Grant Taylor) have posted at least five. Usage patterns have remained unpredictable throughout the season, making it challenging to designate anyone a closer under his guidance. There is also a chance Taylor could be stretched out for a spot in the rotation next year, similar to how the franchise has developed Chris Sale and Garrett Crochet in the past. Amid a rebuild, paying top dollar for a closer does not fit the team’s modus operandi.
As for Leasure, he has recorded a win, three saves, and two holds while posting a 0.364 WHIP with 10 strikeouts against two walks across 11 scoreless frames. Can he build on this momentum next year?
- Pending free agent: Jakob Junis
- Projected 2026 Closer: Cade Smith
It has not all been smooth sailing for Cade Smith since taking over as the closer. However, he has recorded triple-digit strikeouts in each of the last two seasons and converted 12 of 15 saves since August 4. Entering the off-season, planning on Emmanuel Clase not pitching again in the majors remains a possibility. If he does get cleared for a return, it is likely to be with a different franchise.
- Pending free agents: Kyle Finnegan, Tommy Kahnle, Rafael Montero
- Reliever with an option: Paul Sewald (Mutual for $10 million)
- Projected 2026 Closer: TBD
Prefacing this with A.J. Hinch’s preference for not labeling his relievers as closers, the Tigers would be better off pushing all their chips in this winter and reinforcing the bullpen. Continued half-measures in free agency and churning through veterans in hopes of rebounds have not worked. Could Finnegan return on a team-friendly deal below market value at closer? Absolutely. But more must be done in the team’s evaporating “Skubal window.”
- No pending free agents or relievers with options on the 2025 roster
- Projected 2026 Closer: Josh Hader
- Watch List: Brett Gillis
Not only did Josh Hader rebound in 2025, but he was also elite until a shoulder issue sidelined him on August 15. Shoulder injuries can be scary, which makes him a reliever fantasy managers will monitor closely this winter. If you are risk-averse, he may not be on your radar for 2026. It also may make Bryan Abreu a must-handcuff or sneaky late-round target.
- Pending Free Agent: Hunter Harvey
- Projected 2026 Closer: Carlos Estévez
- Watch List: Dennis Colleran
Exceeding anyone’s expectations with his first 40-save campaign, Carlos Estévez will return as the closer in 2026. This year, he was a value in the preseason; next year, fantasy players will pay full price for his save total, making him riskier from a price point perspective.
- Pending Free Agents: Kenley Jansen, Andrew Chafin, Luis García
- Projected 2026 Closer: TBD
- Watch List: Najer Victor
A reunion of Kenley Jansen and the Angels feels inevitable as he pursues 500 career saves. This lets Ben Joyce and Robert Stephenson return to full health without the pressure of being the closer.
- No pending free agents
- Reliever with an option: Justin Topa (Club for $2 million)
- Projected 2026 Closer: David Festa
Remember when Jhoan Duran was an oft-injured starting pitcher prospect who remained healthy and thrived as a reliever? In 25 career major league appearances, David Festa‘s splits by these two pitches:
- Change-up: 28 K-BB%, .268 weighted on-base average (wOBA), 20.4 SwStr%
- Slider: 22.3 K-BB%, .266 weighted on-base average (wOBA), 14.4 SwStr%
Health and his eventual role will determine how prescient this will be, but crazier things have happened.
- Pending Free Agents: Devin Williams, Luke Weaver
- Relievers with options: Jonathan Loáisiga (Club for $5 million), Tim Hill (Club for $3 million)
- Projected 2026 Closer: David Bednar
Since his acquisition, David Bednar has converted eight of 11 save opportunities with 14 games finished of 19 appearances, spanning 21.2 innings. He has posted a 0.923 WHIP with 30 strikeouts against seven walks (27.1 K-BB%) and a 15.5 swinging strike percentage.
- Pending Free Agent: Caleb Ferguson
- Reliever with an option: Andrés Muñoz (Club for $6 million)
- Projected 2026 Closer: Andrés Muñoz
Faced with a decision even a caveman can handle, the Mariners will trigger their option to retain Muñoz. Once again, the team should target veterans capable of setting up for him, but they do well making the most of their bullpen options.
- No pending free agents
- Reliever with an option: Pete Fairbanks (Club for $11 million)
- Projected 2026 Closer: TBD
Hitting his contract bonuses this season, Fairbanks has raised his potential salary from $7 million to over $11 million by virtue of his career highs in innings (58.1) and saves (27). But if the team picks up his option, which goes against how the Rays construct a bullpen, Fairbanks will be a free agent at the end of 2026. He’s a likely candidate for a trade before the season begins.
If this happens, and Griffin Jax does not enter the rotation, he’s my pick for closer next year. However, if Jax is stretched out as a starter, our preference shifts to Edwin Uceta, although it could revert to a matchup-based bullpen.
- Pending Free Agents: Shawn Armstrong, Phil Maton, Chris Martin, Hoby Milner, Danny Coulombe
- Projected 2026 Closer: TBD
- Watch List: Eric Loomis
A massive roster overhaul looms for this franchise. Can Emiliano Teodo and Marc Church step up while remaining healthy next year? Will Josh Sborz return? Will they bring in a veteran on an incentive-based deal? From a fantasy perspective, does it matter?
- Pending Free Agent: Sean Newcomb, José Leclerc
- Projected 2026 Closer: TBD
Since trading Mason Miller, five different relievers have combined for ten saves in a match-up-based approach by Mark Kotsay. Next year’s preferred save share is not on the roster.
- Pending Free Agent: Seranthony Domínguez
- Projected 2026 Closer: Jeff Hoffman
To say the least, it’s been a tumultuous first season as a closer for Jeff Hoffman. Through his team’s first 156 games, he has suffered seven blown saves and allowed 15 home runs while converting 32 saves. His results have varied by month, and he’s entering the postseason with diminished velocity:

He will be an intriguing reliever for debate this winter regarding his fantasy value.
Thanks for being part of the Closer Monkey community. Stay safe, and be well.
Statistical Credits:

































